From Transcribe Wiki
Revision as of 11:01, 25 May 2019 by Scripto (Talk | contribs)

Jump to: navigation, search

Hagar vs Idle } - I by leave to submit to the Court a motion for new trial of the [issue?] in this case - It is a case which I mentioned to Maj'r Sheffry before he went away - and he had no objection to my submitting the motion, in his absence - The jury have found for the plaintiff Hagar, and the judge has certified that in his opinion the verdict is against the weight of evidence - After the judge had granted this certificate, then on the motion of the pltfs counsel, he certifies what was the evidence before the jury - I [suppose?] that in this case, as this issue was not directed to satisfy the conscience of the Chancellor, but was, in effect if not in form, a new trial of a cause depending originally before the Court of law, the judges certificate will be conclusive - If the judge had possessed the power, he would certainly have